The Paper Bag Test: What It Was and Where It Came From
The Paper Bag Test noun · historical practice
A brown paper bag held up against skin. Lighter than the bag, you were in. Darker, you were not.
It was used at the door. Parties, social clubs, some churches, some campus organizations. The bag was ordinary, which was the point; it required no equipment and no explanation, and everybody understood the result without anyone having to say a word.
Where it came from
Colorism in Black America did not begin with the bag. It began with a system that assigned different work, different treatment and different futures based on proximity to whiteness, and it outlasted the system that created it. The bag was one of the ways that logic got carried forward by the people it had been used against.
That is the uncomfortable part, and skipping it makes the history useless. The test was administered inside the community, by Black people, to other Black people.
Why the phrase survived
Most people who use the phrase now have never seen a bag held up to anyone. It survives because the sorting survived.
It turns up in who gets cast, who gets called pretty first, which cousin gets told she is the pretty one and which one gets told she is the smart one. It turns up in the phrase "but you're light skin," said to someone being told their Blackness is conditional.
The bag is gone. The door it was used at is still there in places.
Saying it out loud
A thing that was used quietly does not lose its power until it gets said at a normal volume, in a room where people can disagree about it.
That is the whole reason this one is a card in our deck and not a footnote.
The Paper Bag Test is card No. 135 in Rhetorically Black, the game. Rhetorically Speaking is our free daily newsletter.
Comments